By: Mike Huesmann
For each of the P4 conferences and the G5 as one, I will release a midseason report. Each conference will have a coach who, through the first half of the season, has: overperformed, underperformed, is on the hottest seat, and one for whom the jury is still out on, meaning we need to see how the second half of the season goes before jumping to conclusions. There will also be MVC (most valuable coach). This MVC is for preparation and in-game coaching, not offseason stuff such as roster building in recruiting and the portal. A coach is only eligible to be picked for one category so we won’t have any repeats. Yesterday we kicked off with the SEC Midseason Coaching Report.
Overperforming
Bret Bielema, Illinois
Illinois is 5-1 with their lone loss on the road at Penn State. The schedule gets a lot tougher, but I’m only grading to this point. In August, if you’d have said they’d be 5-1 through that schedule, anyone would have taken it. They haven’t always looked great, but they are getting wins.
"That place should be rocking. That place should be going crazy."
Bret Bielema wants @IlliniFootball fans to bring it for Saturday's ranked matchup vs. No. 24 Michigan 🔊#B1GFootball pic.twitter.com/YBwOzsDiFK
— Big Ten Network (@BigTenNetwork) October 15, 2024
Underperforming
Ryan Walters, Purdue
Walters will go into year three, next year, on the hot seat. This Purdue team is 1-5 with no FBS wins. They aren’t doing many things right, the defense is non-existent, but they at least put up a fight yesterday against Illinois. They may not win a conference game this year.
Ryan Walters' boldest choice yet as #Purdue's football coach came in the middle of the night — but not as an epiphany.https://t.co/RgicxRjSqD
— Nathan Baird (@nwbaird) October 15, 2024
More Sports News
Hottest Seat
Lincoln Riley, USC
There will be some in USC camps who will want to pay him a severance and say, “hit the road.” I don’t think it happens this year, unless he really runs afoul of the wrong people. Lincoln’s heavy contract, I think, puts him on the 2025 hot seat with a small chance of losing his job this year. It would take a terrible end to this season for him to be out. We might not see any Big 10 teams change coaches this offseason, making this category more speculative.
Lincoln Riley's last five QBs are starting in the NFL 😳
(h/t @CFBMaxChadwick) pic.twitter.com/3it4dmoHmc
— ESPN College Football (@ESPNCFB) October 12, 2024
Coldest Seat (most job security)
Kirk Ferentz, Iowa
The powers that be, namely boosters and financial supporters in Iowa City, have his back, and he isn’t going anywhere. He won his 200th game this season, which is an elite list. The Hawkeyes are 4-2 this year with respectable losses to Iowa State and Ohio State, both potential playoff teams. This will be the 12th bowl appearance in a row for Ferentz.
Here's the full clip of Beth Goetz congratulating Kirk Ferentz on his 200th Big Ten win
"200 moments for all those student-athletes and all of those fans who have lived those with you…" pic.twitter.com/MydkGxLCeI
— Blake Hornstein (@BlakeHornTV) October 12, 2024
Jury Still Out (we need to see how the 2nd half of the season goes)
Mike Locksley, Maryland
Locksley has been solid at Maryland. They have progressively improved and have won at least seven games in three consecutive years. He’s never been spectacular though, and I do wonder if the boosters and Maryland people may eventually want more. This year the Terps are 3-3 and do not look good. They are 0-3 in the Big 10 and haven’t beaten anybody who’s on their level. I am curious how the remaining six games go, if it ends poorly, 2025 may be a must win season.
Mike Locksley on Northwestern blowout, "philosophical" difference in taking play-calling from Josh Gattishttps://t.co/1xtrA84vAf
— Andrew (@UMichalumnus) October 14, 2024
MVC (Most Valuable Coach)
Curt Cignetti, Indiana
He’s probably the national coach of the year to this point. It is remarkable that he has the Hoosiers at 6-0, I don’t care what the schedule is. He did it at JMU, now he’s doing it in Bloomington. This team hadn’t won six games in a year since the 2020 COVID year, now they did it to start a season.
What Hoosiers coach Curt Cignetti had to say about the #Huskers. https://t.co/We0qI48cV4
— 𝙷𝚞𝚜𝚔𝚎𝚛𝙼𝚊𝚡 (@Huskermax) October 14, 2024