Okay, I’ve had a few days to process the Early Signing Period and evaluate all the classes put together. I don’t use some mathematical formula created to eliminate bias to determine my rankings.
I don’t care if you think I’m biased or not. This is my top 25 based on player talent, needs that were addressed, and overall roster improvement.
The Top 25
1. Alabama
I won’t bore you with the hits as they have so many. Two legit QBs and every position is a home run down to recent surprises like OL Kadyn Proctor and DB Desmond Ricks. Okay maybe they could have used another linebacker but that’s nitpicking.
Context on Kadyn Proctor's comments about wanting to go to Bama. Felt he would be settling if he went to Iowa in the sense that he wanted to be around guys better than him#RollTide class rank #1
6 5-star players
20 4-stars#Hawkeyes class (37th)
0 5-star players
1 4-star player pic.twitter.com/1qQt9ZcI7y— Scott Reister (@scottreister) December 21, 2022
2. Georgia
To be this highly ranked without a QB in the class is very rare the way I evaluate it. The defensive side is beyond elite led by DEs Samuel M’Pemba and Damon Wilson.
EDGE Samuel M'Pemba has signed with Georgia. #Godawgs pic.twitter.com/Vl54wpre8q
— The DGD Podcast (@thedgdpodcast) December 21, 2022
More Sports News
3. Ohio State
The Buckeyes didn’t finish as strong as hoped and struggled at DE in the end but this offensive class is epic, especially at WR with studs like Noah Rogers, Carnell Tate, and Brandon Inniss.
Carnell Tate finished his tremendous high school career with 2 TDs
Next Stop: Columbus
https://t.co/ZwtKJWuLPg— The Victory Bell (@VictoryBellOSU) November 19, 2022
4. Texas
Everyone knows I’m not as high on QB Arch Manning as many others but he’s still a legit talent and the impact he had on this class was amazing. LB Anthony Hill leads a strong defensive class which will be much needed heading to the SEC soon.
Welcome Home, @ArchManning ?#AllGas23 pic.twitter.com/kHwJQSX59h
— Texas Football (@TexasFootball) December 21, 2022
5. Oklahoma
Led by QB Jackson Arnold the offense is solid but they really improved on defense with DB Peyton Bowen and others.
Congrats to Denton Guyer's @_JacksonArnold_ on being named the MaxPreps Texas Player of the Year.
The 5-star Oklahoma commit accounted for 4,400 yards of total offense and 57 touchdowns in 2022. @DentonGuyer_FB
✍️: https://t.co/ezOcadncIc pic.twitter.com/47z3Xmxevr
— Zack Poff (@Zack_Poff_MP) December 20, 2022
6. Miami
Mario Cristobal’s first class is beyond elite despite five-star DB Cormani McClain delaying his signature. Cristobal especially nailed it in the trenches.
Hurricane Honcho ?? #Pancakehoncho #Canes pic.twitter.com/1VCEUq1y2y
— Samson Okunlola ‘23 (@SAMSONOKUNLOLA_) December 30, 2022
7. LSU
Brian Kelly knows how easy it can be to recruit at LSU and he took advantage of in-state advantages. But Kelly also did an excellent job spot-recruiting nationally at some of the areas he loaded up on at Notre Dame, such as landing four-star TE Mac Markway out of St. Louis, Missouri.
Proud to announce I am committed to Louisiana State University????#GueaxTigers?@LSUfootball @CoachBrianKelly @BrianPolian @MikeDenbrock @SteepDiesel @Coach_TMalone @SWiltfong247 @Rivals_Clint @Julie_Boudwin @ScarboroughMike pic.twitter.com/GtwYtkkf5D
— Mac Markway (@mac_markway) March 24, 2022
8. Clemson
Clemson always has a class outside the top five that seems exceptional and this year is no different. He killed it in Alabama and Georgia as usual, including stealing Christopher Vizzina from in-state schools like Alabama and Auburn.
All In! Clemson has landed a big-time signal caller, check out Christopher Vizzina's Panini #Elite11 QB Breakdown!@vizzina2 || @ClemsonFB#We2Deep23? pic.twitter.com/1okliLedaL
— Elite11 (@Elite11) December 21, 2022
9. Oregon
Dan Lanning dominated down the stretch flipping QB Austin Novosad from Baylor and stealing DE Matayo Uiagalelei from USC and Ohio State. This is as good a class as I’ve seen at Oregon in ages.
Sco Ducks? pic.twitter.com/paSMec0YeV
— Austin Novosad (@Austin2novosad) December 21, 2022
10. Notre Dame
They lost a few key players down the stretch of course but this class addresses needs at WR and RB especially and QB Kenny Minchey is a solid steal late.
Notre Dame pick up a commitment from 4⭐️ QB Kenny Minchey.
Class of 23.
He is the 21st blue chip prospect to commit for Marcus Freeman in the 2023 class. pic.twitter.com/syzQk3msm7
— Unnecessary Roughness (@UnnecRoughness) November 22, 2022
11. Tennessee
QB Nico Iamaleava headlines a solid offensive class but I’m more excited about the defense led by DE Daevin Hobbs.
Home sweet home!
The Cali signal caller is officially a Vol@nico_iamaleava8 | #RockyTop23 ? pic.twitter.com/i2cU4AdH1N
— Tennessee Football (@Vol_Football) December 21, 2022
12. USC
I have USC higher than most because my No. 1 player, QB Malachi Nelson, is a difference maker. The class isn’t as good on defense as I expected but this offense will continue to hum.
Malachi Nelson is officially a USC Trojan! ✌️
The No. 1 overall player in the 2023 ESPN 300 class is headed to LA! pic.twitter.com/sFiutKxxAz
— ESPN College Football (@ESPNCFB) December 21, 2022
13. Florida
This is a strong defensive class which is key and QB Jaden Rashada was a massive flip from Miami.
Be like Jaden.
Welcome to Gator Nation, @jadenrashada!#GoGators | #D23AMTEAM pic.twitter.com/A7TjUOKwNc
— Florida Gators Football (@GatorsFB) December 21, 2022
14. Texas A&M
Despite a horrible season, the Aggies got stronger in the trenches with this class and that’s key. But QB is still an issue.
Texas A&M is the first college football program ever to follow a #1 national recruiting class with a losing season.
Head coach Jimbo Fisher's current buyout: $85.95 million. pic.twitter.com/NzByn2dknC
— Front Office Sports (@FOS) November 13, 2022
15. Penn State
An elite class on the offensive line and tight end will keep them effective running the ball and in short yardage and the defensive backfield is deep.
The BEST in PA…STAY in PA!
J'ven "BamBam" Williams is officially a Nittany Lion ?? @williams_jven#WeAre23 | #NSD pic.twitter.com/DyksdI7oEb
— Penn State Football (@PennStateFball) December 21, 2022
16. South Carolina
A really strong defensive line class headlines one of the better classes I’ve seen for the Gamecocks.
#24EverToThee?? pic.twitter.com/fcjSMPIpXC
— LaNorris Sellers (@LanorriSellers) December 28, 2022
17. Utah
This is the best class I’ve seen Utah put together in my 25 years covering recruiting. That’s bad news for the rest of the PAC 12.
Welcome to the #OBLOCK, @FanoSpencer! pic.twitter.com/nFF1CgB9mZ
— Utah Football (@Utah_Football) December 21, 2022
18. Florida State
A smaller class gets dinged in math formulas but this class is quality over quantity and the offensive additions are nasty.
Committed! Go Noles ?@FSUFootball @Coach_Norvell @Coach_Tokarz @CoachAAtkins pic.twitter.com/lDGlj82jMO
— Brock Glenn (@Brock1Glenn) November 21, 2022
19. TCU
The playoff season had an impact on recruiting and this is one of the best defensive classes in the country.
Trenches are getting scary ?@MarkisDeal11 inks with the Frogs.#GoFrogs #DFWBig12Team #RiffRam23 pic.twitter.com/yZsg44qOmi
— TCU Football (@TCUFootball) December 21, 2022
20. Auburn
Hugh Freeze came in and stole players from Ohio State, Florida State, and elsewhere. He sent a message with his first class.
#wareagle ?let’s do it pic.twitter.com/7aGuuz8YFs
— Luh Kay (@_kayinlee) December 21, 2022
21. Michigan State
In another small class that won’t get the love of math formulas, Mel Tucker nailed it on defense.
Home sweet home ?@AndrewDepaepe2 is official!#NEXT2T3P pic.twitter.com/BRUgGyuhFJ
— Michigan State Football (@MSU_Football) December 21, 2022
22. Michigan
Wide receiver help is on the way for a class that isn’t ranked as high as expected but you can’t argue Jim Harbaugh’s evaluation skills.
Proud of y’all boys❤️?❤️? #GoBlue #GoCowboys pic.twitter.com/UZ4blbC4ZM
— Marquesse hill (@MarquesseHill) December 22, 2022
23. Arkansas
The balance of this class stands out to me as Sam Pittman didn’t miss anywhere.
Metcalfs and football seem to go well together
Welcome HOME @tjmetcalf3 pic.twitter.com/i0zOQD3wF9
— Arkansas Razorback Football (@RazorbackFB) December 21, 2022
24. Texas Tech
Joey McGuire lands a ton of in-state talent as expected and will immediately improve his defense.
Post’s Isaiah Crawford got his Guns Up after signing to play college football at Texas Tech! pic.twitter.com/f8IKlqA7FL
— Pete Christy (@pchristy11) December 21, 2022
25. Mississippi State
There aren’t a ton of stars in here but the middle of this class is loaded with future two deep standouts.
?️ ???? ??? ???? ?️
cc: @C_Parson2 #NSD23 x #HailState?☠️ pic.twitter.com/jJjj7O3jOx
— Mississippi State Football (@HailStateFB) December 21, 2022