Analyzing Drew Allar and the Top Returning Big Ten QBs

By Dorrington Myers

---

Last time out, I broke down the ACC quarterbacks and what they bring to the table. Now, I’m shifting my focus to the best of the Big Ten. Quarterback play was a major factor in determining this year’s national champion, and the Big Ten stood out as one of the most productive conferences in terms of efficiency and performance. Here are my top five quarterbacks from the conference.

---

Drew Allar, Penn State

Synopsis: Entering next season as the top quarterback in the conference comes with lofty expectations. To me, Allar is the most pro-ready when you evaluate his total body of work and got late buzz to declare for the 2025 draft. However, I’d like to see him refine his situational awareness in critical moments. Additionally, starting fast and maintaining that rhythm throughout the game will be key to taking his game to the next level.

Key Stats and Achievements: 66.5% completion rate, 24 touchdowns to 8 interceptions, led Penn State to a College Football Playoff semifinal appearance. The Nittany Lions were so close to the national title, Allar will use this as motivation. 

Strengths: 

• Arm strength

• Frame

• Poise/maturity

• Mechanics

• IQ

---

Luke Altmyer, Illinois

Synopsis: Altmyer is a crafty quarterback with a high football IQ, giving him a strong feel for the game. Recently, most of his throws have come from pure progression concepts, so I’d like to see him read defenses beyond that structure. Additionally, improving his ball placement will be key to his development. The ability to consistently deliver catchable throws is rare, and refining this skill could elevate his game even further. Outside of that, he has all the tools to succeed.

Key Stats and Achievements: 22 touchdowns to six interceptions, led Illinois to a Citrus Bowl victory over South Carolina and a 10-win season.

Strengths:

• IQ

• Arm talent

• Mobility

• Quick release

---

Fernando Mendoza, Indiana

Synopsis: At Cal, he was impactful, leading the charge. However, there are two key areas where Mendoza needs to improve. First, he must get the ball out of his hands faster to avoid unnecessary sacks. Second, Mendoza needs to be more efficient in the red zone. Indiana provides a great opportunity for him to refine these skills.

Key Stats and Achievements: 68.7% completion rate, 3,004 yards, 16 touchdowns

Strengths:

• Accuracy

• Poise under pressure

• Decision-making.

---

Dylan Raiola, Nebraska

Synopsis: People can say whatever they want about this young man—he’s still going to go out and perform. As a freshman, he played like one, trying to make plays and sometimes forcing the issue. With time and development, we’ll see him reduce turnovers and erratic decisions. He’s undoubtedly talented, which is why he makes my list. People hate that he models his game after Patrick Mahomes. Just like anyone that’s a fan, he can do that as well. I see no wrongdoing here. 

Key Stats and Achievements: 67.1% completion rate, 2,819 yards, led Nebraska to a Pinstripe Bowl victory against Boston College.

Strengths:

• Arm talent

• Pocket presence

• Deep ball accuracy

• Leadership

---

Demond Williams Jr., Washington

Synopsis: I was personally impressed with his performance during his freshman campaign. Williams Jr. is a rare gem. While his height and stature at 5’11” 187 pounds may cause some NFL to hesitate down the road, I believe that’s the only real knock on him at this moment—aside from experience. After splitting time with Will Rogers last year, this is his job going into 2025 and will have a full offseason of starting reps.

Key Stats and Achievements: QBR 84.3, eight touchdowns to one interception, led the Huskies to the Sun Bowl.

Strengths: 

• Mobility

• Pocket awareness

• Accuracy

• IQ

• Toughness