• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Mike Farrell Sports

Mike Farrell Sports

College Football Recruiting, Opinion, and Analysis

  • Player Promotion
  • Recruiting
  • Transfer Portal
  • Latest News
  • NFL Draft
  • About

Replacing Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, Drake Maye, Michael Penix Jr., and JJ McCarthy

High expectations are always present when replacing elite quarterbacks like what Miller Moss may have to do

Avatar photoDorrington Myers| May 23, 2024 (Updated: July 24, 2025)
FacebookTweetPin
Dec 27
Dec 27

By Dorrington Myers


As the echoes of the championship celebrations fade and the stadium lights dim until spring, the excitement of college football takes a different form. The offseason has begun, and with it comes the promise of a fresh start and the thrill of new beginnings. Coaches are hitting the recruiting trail with relentless vigor, and the anticipation for spring practice builds among players and fans alike. But one question looms large over the program: Who will step up as the next QB1?

With the departure of the team’s main signal callers, a new chapter is about to be written in the annals of our football legacy. The race for the starting quarterback position is wide open, sparking speculation and debate from locker rooms to living rooms. Will it be the seasoned veteran who has patiently waited for his turn? Or will a highly touted recruit take the reins and lead us to glory? Perhaps a talented transfer, seeking redemption and a chance to shine, will emerge as the leader.

This spring promises to be a crucible of competition, a proving ground where arm strength, poise, and leadership will be tested. As the contenders prepare to showcase their skills, fans and analysts alike are gearing up for what could be one of the most exhilarating quarterback battles in recent memory. Get ready, because the quest for QB1 is about to begin—and it’s going to be a wild ride.

As we look ahead to the 2024 college football season, several top programs are facing the challenge of replacing their star quarterbacks who have moved on to the NFL. Here’s a detailed analysis of the new quarterback situations at USC, LSU, UNC, Washington, and Michigan.


USC

Key Departure:

  • Caleb Williams: Drafted first overall by the Chicago Bears in the 2024 NFL Draft.

Current Roster

  • Miller Moss, R-Junior

More Sports News

Arch Manning

Can Arch Manning Do What Peyton and Eli Did Not?

Curt Cignetti

SEC vs. Big Ten: Is Indiana Adopting the SEC’s Scheduling Model?

Review of FCS Championship Odds

Maddux Madsen

2025 MWC: Can Boise State Hold Off the Rising Contenders?

The logo of the Big Ten Conference is seen on a yard marker during Iowa Hawkeyes football Kids Day at Kinnick open practice

TRENDING: Big Ten Head Coach Suspends Former Five-Star WR Indefinitely

Ty Simpson

Ty Simpson Era Begins: Alabama’s New QB Ready for 2025 Run

Ryan Day

Ryan Day’s 2025 Ohio State Buckeyes Embrace Attack Mode

John Mateer

Oklahoma QB Mateer Faces Venmo Gambling Allegations

This SEC Head Coach Could Be on The Hot Seat in December

Jeremiah Smith

Ohio State’s Offensive Reload: Chasing Back-to-Back Titles

Caleb Wheatland

Auburn Tigers New Defensive Faces for 2025

This ACC Head Coach Could Be on The Hot Seat in December

  • Jayden Maiava, R-Sophomore
  • Jake Jensen, R-Junior
  • Gage Roy, Junior

Analysis:

Miller Moss is the clear front-runner to take over the starting quarterback position at USC. Moss showcased his potential with a masterful performance in the Holiday Bowl, where he threw for 372 yards and six touchdowns in his first career start. His precise and efficient play demonstrated his readiness to lead the Trojans’ offense. With Moss at the helm, USC fans can expect a smooth transition from Caleb Williams.

Dec 27, 2023; San Diego, CA, USA; USC Trojans quarterback Miller Moss (7) throws a pass against the Louisville Cardinals during the first half at Petco Park.

LSU

Key Departure:

  • Jayden Daniels: Heisman Trophy winner in 2023 and second overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft to Washington.

Current Roster:

  • Garrett Nussmeier, R-Junior
  • AJ Swann, Junior 
  • Rickie Collins, R-Freshman
  • Colin Hurley, Freshman

Analysis:

Garrett Nussmeier is expected to take the reins for the Tigers. Known for his confidence and competitive nature, Nussmeier embodies the leadership qualities needed to drive LSU forward. Rickie Collins has also shown promise, displaying confidence with the offense. The combination of Nussmeier’s leadership and Collins’ developing skills bodes well for LSU’s future.

Dec 3, 2022; Atlanta, GA, USA; LSU Tigers quarterback Garrett Nussmeier (13) drops back to pass against the Georgia Bulldogs during the third quarter of the SEC Championship game at Mercedes-Benz Stadium.

North Carolina

Key Departure:

  • Drake Maye: Third overall pick by the New England Patriots in the 2024 NFL Draft.

Current Roster:

  • DJ Mazzone, Freshman
  • Max Johnson, Graduate
  • Connor Harrell, Sophomore
  • Michael Merdinger, Freshman

Analysis:

Max Johnson, with his experience playing in the SEC prior to transferring, stands as the front-runner for the Tar Heels. His mobility and experience will be critical in maintaining the offensive momentum established by Drake Maye. Connor Harrell, a dual-threat quarterback, has also shown significant improvement in his accuracy, making him a strong contender.

Nov 4, 2023; Oxford, Mississippi, USA; Texas A&M Aggies quarterback Max Johnson (14) passes the ball against the Mississippi Rebels during the second half at Vaught-Hemingway Stadium.

Washington

Key Departure:

  • Michael Penix Jr.: Eighth overall pick by the Atlanta Falcons in the 2024 NFL Draft.

Current Roster:

  • Desmond Williams Jr., Freshman
  • Will Rogers, Senior
  • Teddy Purcell, Junior

Analysis:

Desmond Williams Jr. may be a freshman, but he plays with the poise and maturity of an upperclassman. His reps with the first offense have been impressive. Will Rogers, with his strong arm capable of stretching the field, also remains a significant option for the Huskies. The competition between these two will be one to watch as the season progresses.

Sep 24, 2022; Starkville, Mississippi, USA; Mississippi State Bulldogs quarterback Will Rogers (2) looks to pass against the Bowling Green Falcons during the first quarter at Davis Wade Stadium at Scott Field.

Michigan

Key Departure:

  • JJ McCarthy: Tenth overall pick by the Minnesota Vikings in the 2024 NFL Draft.

Current Roster:

  • Jaydn Davis, Freshman
  • Jayden Denegal, Junior
  • Alex Orji, Junior
  • Anthony Arnoue, Senior
  • Davis Warren, Senior
  • Jack Tuttle, Graduate

Analysis:

Alex Orji is known for his dynamic play both on the ground and through the air, showcasing exceptional arm talent. Freshman Jaydn Davis has also impressed, showing remarkable arm talent and a smooth operation of the offense. The depth and talent in Michigan’s quarterback room will provide ample competition, pushing each player to excel.

Blue Team quarterback Alex Orji (10) makes a pass against Maize Team during the second half of the spring game at Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor on Saturday, April 20, 2024.

In summary, each of these top programs has promising options to replace their departed star quarterbacks. The upcoming season will be a true test of their depth and ability to develop new leaders under center. Fans can look forward to exciting performances as these quarterbacks step up to fill big shoes.

Category: College Football, NewsTag: AJ Swann, Alex Orji, Anthony Arnoue, Caleb Williams, Colin Hurley, Conner Harrell, Davis Warren, Demond Williams, DJ Mazzone, Drake Maye, Gage Roy, Garrett Nussmeier, Jadyn Davis, Jake Jensen, Jayden Daniels, Jayden Denegal, Jayden Maiava, JJ McCarthy, LSU Tigers, Max Johnson, Michael Merdinger, Miller Moss, North Carolina Tar Heels, Rickie Collins, Teddy Purcell, USC Trojans, Washington Huskies, Will Rogers
FacebookTweetPin

You’ll Also Like


Jim Harbaugh

Michigan Wolverines Get Hammered, Do Not Vacate Any Wins

Which Top FCS Offensive Linemen Might End Up in the Portal?

Manning Award

Arch Manning Snubbed From Preseason List

Former SEC Backup QB Trending to Become ACC Starter

Ohio State

2025 College Football Championship Predictions by Conference

Vinny Anthony II

Badgers Blueprint: Path to 8 Wins


  • Facebook
  • X
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

© 2025 · All Rights Reserved

Powered by the BizBudding Publisher Network

Privacy Manager